The Great Goddess Theory
The Theory
My personal favorite is the Venus of Willendorf, discovered in what is now Austria, dated to between 33,000 and 20,000 years ago.
The Venus of Moravany, Slovakia, created 24,800 years ago
Figurines from Balzi Rossi, Italy, 24,000 to 19,000 years old
Most of these, as you can see, are paleolithic; yet there are some dated to Eve's time: the figurine from Catalhoyuk and the figurine from the Halaf culture.
Many of these figurines were considered to be "fertility tokens" simply because they depicted a female form. A discussion of the inherent sexism of that argument is here.
The idea of there being one mother deity, from which all other feminine goddesses sprung, was initially the brainchild of German archaeologist Friedrich Wilhelm Eduard Gerhard in 1849. Gerhard was a classicist, which means he studied Greco-Roman history between the years of 800BC-500AD. Gerhard elaborated on this idea with a publication in 1855, in which he hypothesized that the female deities of the time – favorites like Hera, Aphrodite, and Athena - came from a primitive deity: Gaia, which he called an “earth and creation goddess.”
The idea took root among archaeological scholars, and eventually grew limbs and walked to evolve into something that, while rooted deeply in mythology, has little to do with reality.
Evidence to Support
The primary evidence of the Great Goddess Theory are so-called "Venus figurines;" statues from the Upper Paleolithic era (from 50,000 to 12,000 years ago) that depict women with exaggerated female figures. The similarities are obvious to the naked eye, which is probably why this theory was so popular for so long.
The oldest Venus Figurine found is the Venus of Hohle Fels, discovered in what is now Germany in 2008. This Venus is dated to between between 42,000 and 40,000 years ago.
My personal favorite is the Venus of Willendorf, discovered in what is now Austria, dated to between 33,000 and 20,000 years ago.
Here are some other examples, so you can see the similarities yourself:
The Venus of Moravany, Slovakia, created 24,800 years ago
Figurines from Balzi Rossi, Italy, 24,000 to 19,000 years old
Many of these figurines were considered to be "fertility tokens" simply because they depicted a female form. A discussion of the inherent sexism of that argument is here.
Evidence Against
The Great Goddess theory is no longer taken seriously by historians. While it makes sense that multiple cultures would worship a fertility goddess with exaggerated feminine features – women give birth to and nurture children, who are vital to the continuance of society – there is no evidence that the different cultures who made these statues revered the same deity.
Archaeological evidence does not bear this out, with later deities being depicted with a catalogue of unique symbology. Athena is represented by clearly different symbols than Hera, who is different from Inanna, and so on. There is no evidence of a singular common origin.
The trouble with ancient history is that there is very little evidence left. Well-informed historians try their best to fill in the gaps, but some things may remain a mystery. We know little about the gender roles of neolithic or prehistoric times, and it is difficult to put together what the structure of society may have been like from scant pottery sherds. It is extremely likely that ancient people's understanding of gender, sex, marriage, and reproduction as a whole is completely different than our own.
The Takeaway
The Cult of Eve is ultimately a work of fiction, and as tantalizing as the Mother Goddess may seem, there is no real, compelling archaeological evidence to support her existence. That said, there are no shortage of religions that emphasize of the importance of the Divine Masculine and Feminine, including Abrahamic religions and the Latter-Day Saints.
And, of course, the nature of religious beliefs is that there is not and will never be any real, solid proof of their existence -- that is why religion depends on faith. The Divine Masculine and Feminine are as real as you or I, as long as you believe in their existence.
Oldest Depiction of Eve
I've been searching for the earliest depiction of Eve, and with my limited resources, am having limited success. The oldest I have found so far is the Sarcophagus of Agape and Crescentius, dated to between 325-350 AD, which is housed in one of the Vatican Mueseums. It "was found in 1841, along with other cartefacts, in the area near the Vatican City railway station."
Comments
Post a Comment